Home » General

Are You “Spiritually Challenged”?

28 April 2004 2 Comments

Are You “Spiritually Challenged”? I really do not know how to interpret this question. If you look at this via the eyes of political correctiveness, one would think that this means a person who lacks spirituality similar to the politically correct term ‘vertically challenged’ used to describe short people. However, if you look at this normally, one would interpret the question to mean “Is a man challenged spiritually to be the best Christian he can be?”

Well, according to the article entitled “Christian men: Faith not a challenge”, a survey conducted by Promise Keepers concluded that:

…shows Christian men don’t see issues of faith and spirituality as challenges in their lives, focusing more on family, work and health concerns…

…Rather than issues regarding their faith or spiritual growth, respondents said family and children (42 percent) are a top “challenge” in their lives, along with career/money (39 percent) and health concerns (20 percent). Just one in eight said spirituality was a challenge to focus on….

I found the following statements troublesome:

….”It’s certainly clear to us that we have a great mission field in front of us in reaching the men of America,” said Tom Fortson, Ph.D., president and CEO of Promise Keepers, in the statement. “Much, much more needs to be done to engage men with their spiritual side, and then to see them make an impact on their families, churches and communities. We’ve only scratched the surface.”….

Gee, what have you done since 1990. Founded by a celebrity college football coach with regional conferences annually with mega-Christian speakers and a big gathering on the Washington D.C. mall between the Capitol Building and the Washington Monument broadcasted on the major Christian television networks, one would think that after reading their history page that they were expanding, growing, and reaching out. However, after reading that statement. The past 14 years have not been as successful as portrayed.

…The men’s group said it was pleased that 68 percent of respondents had heard of Promise Keepers….

…The poll included 415 men chosen randomly and 200 men from Promise Keepers’ own constituent files. All of the respondents identified themselves as “born-again Christian” or “active church attenders.” They hailed from Los Angeles, Seattle, Denver, Dallas, Baltimore and Atlanta.”

Based on that aggregate data and survey pool of all ‘born-again” Christians, only 68 percent of the respondents had heard of Promise Keepers? I find that very hard to believe with the local, statewide, regional, and national networking their members bragged about at their church men’s meetings. One would think that that number would be considerably higher along with the fact that all the men surveyed lived in major metropolitan areas of America where many of their regional conventions were hosted. I am baffled by this. Many men’s groups in America’s churches are really extentions of Promise Keepers where their curriculums are used monthly and they rent a bus and secure hotel rooms once a year {and some use this as a chance to look at the porno channels because it can be hidden on the hotel room bill when away from the wife because of deeper unresolved issues} to go to the regional convention on a weekend, claim they were refreshed, and life became the same thing weeks later at home.

If one analyzes the results of this survey, one has to now see this as a failure that Promise Keepers has spent the last 14 years as a nationally known ministry with Christian and secular news coverage and many of these men are not satisified with their church experience. If you go out on the frontal assault on reaching the men of America, what are you going to reach them with? More feminized neutered male psychobabble mixed in with Republican politics mixed with White Southern American Males are automatic racists? They were having problems reaching out when a major hotel chain came out and stated many years ago that hotel pornography rentals went up drastically during the Promise Keepers retreat weekends. The message to the heart was somehow lost somewhere between the convention center and the hotel room when some of the men rented pornography in the hotel room. It starts when you get real with men and treat men like brothers instead of a drill sargeant / private or a probation officer / criminal mentality too many men’s groups turn into. It starts when we teach men how to overcome and conquer, not just barely survive. It starts when we teach men the true inner workings of their life and not just the answers to the test to bare pass and barely get by.

Promise Keepers, time to get started, time’s (14 years) a wasting.

2 Comments »

  • Russell Lucas said:

    To Whom It May Concern,
    In reading your article I have concluded that you are an opponent of the Promise Keepers movement. It seems as if you feel the movement has more flash than bang and its bark is bigger than its bite. I gather that one of the reasons you feel this way is because it hasn’t succeeded in engaging men regarding spiritual issues. You cited a poll and bemoaned the results that demonstrated men are concerned with work, health, and family issues more than spiritual issues. If this is true, with all due respect, I don’t think you are seeing the issue clearly. It is an improper distinction to seperate “spiritual issues” from things such as work, health and family. Is it spiritual to work hard and earn a living? Is it spiritual to lead your family? Is it spiritual to take care of yourself so you remain healthy? The church has a tendancy to draw a line between spiritual stuff (prayer, evangelism, Bible study) and physical stuff (work, relationships, and family). THIS LINE NEEDS TO BE ERASED!!!!! God is concerned about all aspects of life. Re-examine Proverbs and you will be astounded how much God is concerned with a good work ethic, with relationships and yes health. In the epistles Paul’s exposition is always followed by his exhortation to apply doctrinal truths. These areas are the very places where the rubber of our spiritual beliefs meet the road of our daily lives. It is not a question of either / or. You can’t talk about families, work and health without talking about things that are “of God” and “spiritual” These are the very things God created. Our belief in the spiritual things (God, salvation, demons, etc.) are what dictate HOW we go about leading our wives and our children, establishing our priorities, relating the gospel to co-workers and even exercising daily.
    Regarding PK. Is it perfect? No. But what organization is? We need to hold up and commend what is good and address and build up what is weak. PK has had a tremendous effect on our culture. Are men watching porn at hotels when they are at the conference? Probably. But a PK conference is where these men need to be to get some help. I urge you brother(s) don’t tear down what God has done through others. To say they have wasted fourteen years is to completely deminished what God has done through this organization. Do you feel your organization has done more? I wish mine had one hundredth of the impact for the kingdom as Promise Keepers.

    Sincerely

    Russ Lucas
    Associate Pastor
    Summit View Church

  • Keith Mitchell said:

    I’m looking for a Christian men’s retreat to deal with some issues. I am 35 days sober and am busy cleaning up my life. My marriage is a mess and I need to get it back on track.